Courts
High Court sets aside O'Connell appeal orders
The Court identifies errors in the ACT appeal court's assessment of the jury's verdict and circumstantial evidence.
Where it standsJudgment delivered on 4 November 2026, [2026] HCA 41. Both sets of ACT Court of Appeal orders were set aside.
What happened
The High Court unanimously allowed the DPP's appeal concerning the decision to set aside O'Connell's murder conviction. It held that the appellate majority had not fully allowed for the jury's advantages or assessed all the established circumstances when considering an inference consistent with innocence.
The Court rejected the separate argument that raising concerns with the parties after reserving judgment infringed the adversarial process.
Why it matters
The decision matters to criminal appeals based on an unreasonable verdict: the evidence must be assessed together and the jury's advantages properly considered.
What a firm does with this
Case summaries should separate the successful evidentiary ground from the rejected procedural objection.
Read the source
General information, not legal advice. A summary is not the judgment, bill or release: read the source before you rely on it.