Today in Australian law

Courts

Federal Court invalidates McPhillamys heritage declaration

A procedural failure has undone the Commonwealth protection decision affecting a proposed NSW gold mine, with the application returning to the minister.

CommonwealthEvent:

Where it standsFederal Court judgment delivered. The declaration was held invalid and the application is to be redetermined. Detailed written reasons were not available on the Court website at publication.

What happened

The Federal Court has held invalid the Commonwealth declaration protecting part of the McPhillamys Gold Project site near Blayney, New South Wales, under section 10 of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Heritage Protection Act 1984.

ABC reported that information concerning the Blue Banded Bee Dreaming story amounted in substance to a new application. It should have been referred through the statutory reporting and public consultation process before the minister decided the matter.

The result concerns the lawfulness of the decision-making process, not a judicial rejection of the site's asserted cultural significance. The application returns to the current federal environment minister for redetermination, and costs submissions are due by 27 October.

Why it matters

Judicial review can invalidate a major project decision where legally required consultation and reporting steps are not followed. The ruling does not itself approve the disputed project infrastructure or finally determine the heritage application.

What a firm does with this

Lawgistics action: for public-law intake, record the statutory decision-maker, each mandatory procedural step, what information was introduced at each stage, consultation undertaken, reasons, remedies sought and urgent deadlines. Keep process grounds separate from the merits of the underlying heritage claim.

Read the source

General information, not legal advice. A summary is not the judgment, bill or release: read the source before you rely on it.

Keep reading

All 73 stories