Courts
High Court requires consideration of downstream emissions
A majority upheld the invalidation of approval for the Mount Pleasant mine expansion after a NSW planning failure concerning Scope 3 emissions.
Where it standsFinal High Court judgment. Appeal dismissed with costs by majority.
What happened
In MACH Energy Australia Pty Ltd v Denman Aberdeen Muswellbrook Scone Healthy Environment Group Inc [2026] HCA 35, the High Court dismissed MACH Energy's appeal by majority.
The decisive majority reasoning concerned clause 2.20 of the NSW Resources and Energy planning policy. The Independent Planning Commission had to consider whether conditions should minimise all greenhouse gas emissions to the greatest extent practicable, including downstream Scope 3 emissions, but did not do so.
The judgment does not prohibit the mine's existing operation to 2032 and does not prevent the proposed expansion being reconsidered. It turns on the applicable NSW statutory framework rather than creating a free-standing national climate duty.
Why it matters
NSW project approvals and judicial-review advice must identify every mandatory consideration in the governing planning instruments. Reasons should show an active intellectual process, including for downstream emissions where the instrument requires it.
What a firm does with this
For environmental and planning intake, capture the approval date, decision-maker, governing instrument, emissions categories and every condition considered. Avoid describing the case as a nationwide ban on coal expansions.
Read the source
- High Court: MACH Energy Australia Pty Ltd v DAMSHEG Inc [2026] HCA 35
- NSW Government response, 7 October 2026
General information, not legal advice. A summary is not the judgment, bill or release: read the source before you rely on it.