Courts
High Court preserves judicial review route for Victorian planning dispute
The IGA decision confirms that a statutory restriction cannot exclude Supreme Court review for jurisdictional error in this setting.
Where it standsJudgment delivered, [2026] HCA 43. The Minister's appeal was dismissed; the underlying challenge was not decided on its merits.
What happened
The High Court held by majority that section 39(8) of Victoria's Planning and Environment Act cannot validly prevent a person with sufficient standing seeking Supreme Court relief for jurisdictional error concerning an unapproved planning scheme amendment.
Why it matters
An apparent statutory restriction is not necessarily the end of the judicial review inquiry. This decision addresses access to review, not whether the panel actually committed jurisdictional error.
What a firm does with this
Planning intake should record the amendment's approval stage and obtain specialist review before rejecting a challenge based on section 39.
Read the source
General information, not legal advice. A summary is not the judgment, bill or release: read the source before you rely on it.