Malaysia and Australia

Who pays when the case ends

Costs decide which cases get run at all. Here is how they work in Malaysia and in Victoria, and why the answer shapes the advice a lawyer gives long before trial.

3 min read

Law school teaches you who wins. Practice is quieter than that. In the first conference on a real file, someone always asks the question the textbook skipped: if we win, who pays for all this, and if we lose, what do we owe them.

The starting point is the same in both countries

As a rule, costs follow the event. The losing party pays a share of the winner's legal costs, and the court has a discretion to order otherwise. Malaysia and Victoria both inherited that principle, and both still apply it, so a student moving between the two systems starts on familiar ground.

Two things follow from it immediately. A claim worth less than the cost of running it is usually not worth running. And a party with no money to satisfy a costs order is a different kind of opponent from one who has money, whatever the merits look like.

A share, not the whole bill

The winner almost never recovers everything they paid their own lawyers. What they recover is assessed, and the assessment is deliberately less than the full account. In Victoria that is the standard basis, and the more generous indemnity basis is reserved for cases where something about the losing party's conduct justifies it, such as pressing on with a hopeless claim or ignoring a reasonable offer. Malaysian courts likewise distinguish costs on the ordinary party to party basis from costs on the more generous scale, and can award the higher measure where conduct warrants it.

The gap between what a client pays and what a client recovers is one of the first things that surprises people about litigation. It is also why a good lawyer talks about settlement early and often, rather than at the courtroom door.

Offers change everything

In both systems the party who makes a sensible offer and is proved right is rewarded, and the party who refuses one is punished. In Victoria a formal offer of compromise under the rules, or a Calderbank letter, shifts the costs consequences from the date it was refused. Malaysian practice uses a payment into court and offers made without prejudice save as to costs to do similar work.

The mechanics differ, but the lesson does not. A written offer is not a sign of weakness. It is a costs weapon, and it is usually built by the junior who prepares the numbers.

Security for costs, the other side of the coin

If costs follow the event, a defendant facing a plaintiff who cannot pay has a problem. Both systems answer it the same way. The defendant can ask the court to order the plaintiff to put money up front, as security, before the case goes further. In Malaysia that application is made under Order 23 of the Rules of Court 2012, and Victorian courts have an equivalent power.

It is worth understanding properly, because it is one of the few interlocutory applications that can end a case without anyone deciding who was right. A plaintiff who cannot find the money does not get to run the claim.

Why this matters on internship

Costs are invisible in a judgment summary and impossible to miss in a file. Sit in on a conference and you will hear the number in dispute weighed against the cost of getting to trial, then against the risk of losing, then against how long the other side can afford to keep going. That calculation is most of what commercial litigation actually is.

If you want one comparison essay topic that will teach you more about practice than any other, this is a strong candidate: security for costs, or the costs consequences of a rejected offer, in Malaysia and in Victoria. Both are narrow enough to cover properly in four weeks and real enough that someone in the office will have an opinion about them.

General information about court practice, not legal advice. Costs rules and their application change, and every case turns on its own facts, so check the current position before relying on any of it.

A decision to read with it

Litigation · Practice and Procedure

Can the court cap everyone's future costs without being asked?

Integrated Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Lai [2026] VSC 559

What happened

A building dispute that started in VCAT and was transferred to the Supreme Court. The amounts claimed were modest and the issues were not complex, yet by June 2026 the owners had spent $328,677 on lawyers, the contractor $299,010 and the builder $68,701. The owners were on their third law firm. A Judicial Registrar ordered the contractor to give security for the owners' costs of $49,626.50 in two tranches, and, on her own motion, capped the future recoverable costs of every party at $94,160. The owners appealed. They said the power in s 65C(2)(d) of the Civil Procedure Act 2010 to cap costs in advance can only be used when a party asks for it, and that if there was to be a cap it should be $410,790, the figure their own costs consultant put on their future costs, about four times what the other parties expected to spend.

What the court decided

Appeal dismissed, with the owners to pay the costs of it. An appeal from a judicial registrar under r 84.05 is a hearing de novo, so Delany J decided the questions afresh while giving weight to the reasons below. The court can cap recoverable costs on its own motion: s 65C exists to further the overarching purpose, the factors in s 65C(2A) are a guide and not a checklist, and the Court of Appeal in Bare v Small said as much. The costs already incurred by the contractor and the owners each exceeded the amount in dispute, and s 24 of the Act imposes a positive obligation on the court to ensure costs are not excessive. The same cap was imposed on every party because the reasonable future work was much the same for each. His Honour also barred any further interlocutory application without leave, referred the parties to judicial mediation on 24 September, and left security payable in two tranches so a lump sum did not stultify the claim.

Why it matters

The court does not need to be asked before it caps costs. When what has been spent already exceeds what the case is worth, s 65C and the overarching purpose let a judge cap every party in advance, bar new applications and send everyone to mediation.

What a junior would take from it

Before you draft the next interlocutory application, put the costs to date next to the amount in dispute. If the first number is bigger, the court will notice, and it may be your client who pays for it.

Read the judgment (opens in a new tab)

Read next

The Kuala Lumpur internship: four weeks inside a civil litigation firm, Thomas Philip Advocates and Solicitors.