Malaysia and Australia

Legal writing: Malaysia versus Australia

What changes when you write for a Malaysian supervising lawyer.

3 min read

If you’re an Australian law student coming to Malaysia for an internship, the fastest way to feel confident in week 1 is to realise this:

You already understand the common law thinking style: facts, then issues, then rule, then application.

What changes is the writing culture, which includes tone, structure, citations, formality and, very practically, how you “anchor” your argument to procedure (Malaysia: Orders; Australia: Rules and sections).

Below is the “translation guide” we give our Australian interns so they can write in a way Malaysian litigators and judges immediately recognise.

1. The first adjustment: Malaysia writes through “Orders”, Australia writes through “Rules” and sections

Malaysia: ROC 2012 is organised by Orders

Malaysian civil procedure is written and cited in Orders under the Rules of Court 2012 (ROC 2012). Your drafting often starts by stating the procedural gateway:

  • Order 13 (default of appearance to writ)
  • Order 14 (summary judgment)
  • Order 18 (pleadings)
  • Order 24 (discovery and inspection of documents)

Also note the ROC 2012 explicitly frames itself as a procedural code with an overriding objective that parties must help the Court achieve.

Australia: procedure is usually cited by rule numbers, plus case management “purpose” sections

Australia doesn’t speak in “Orders” the same way. You’ll usually cite rules (Federal Court Rules or the state UCPR) and sometimes the overarching purpose provisions that shape drafting and case management:

  • Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M (overarching purpose)
  • Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) s 56 (overriding purpose)

2. Tone: Australian clarity, Malaysian courtroom restraint

The Australian student default

Australian writing training pushes you toward:

  • plain English
  • confident conclusions
  • minimal ceremony

The Malaysian court facing tone

Malaysian litigation writing is usually:

  • more formal and deferential
  • less “punchy”
  • more careful when alleging serious misconduct

Commonly, you’ll see:

  • “It is respectfully submitted that…”
  • “With respect…”
  • “The Defendant denies… save as expressly admitted…”

A simple “translation” example

Australian flavoured:

“The defendant clearly breached the contract.”

Malaysia flavoured:

“It is respectfully submitted that the Defendant breached the Agreement by failing to make payment by the contractual due date.”

Same meaning, but a different courtroom voice.

3. Structure: Malaysia loves navigable, numbered modules

Australian writing often tolerates more narrative flow.

Malaysian court documents typically prefer:

  • shorter paragraphs
  • aggressive numbering, including sub paragraphs
  • defined terms (“the Agreement”, “the Impugned Decision”)
  • headings that sound like issue questions

Why? Because the ROC 2012 is built to be used like a structured code (Orders, rules, forms), and judges expect your writing to be equally easy to index.

4. A practical checklist for Australian interns

Before you send any draft in Malaysia, ask:

  • What am I drafting: a pleading, an affidavit or submissions?
  • Have I anchored the document to the right procedural gateway? (Malaysia: Order; Australia: rule or section)
  • Does each legal proposition have an authority and a pinpoint?
  • Are my facts tied to pleadings or exhibits?
  • Is my tone appropriately restrained and court facing?

The goal: you leave able to write in a Malaysian legal style without losing your Australian clarity.

Views are the author’s. General information, not legal advice.

A decision to read with it

Litigation · Practice and Procedure

Can you strike out a proportionate liability defence before trial?

BlueCross Community Care Services Group v Buxton Constructions [2026] VSC 581

What happened

BlueCross sued its builder, Buxton, in contract, and its architect, BLP, in contract and negligence, for the cost of fixing defects in a new aged care facility in Box Hill. BLP pleaded that if it was liable, the claim was an apportionable claim under Part IVAA of the Wrongs Act 1958 and Buxton was a concurrent wrongdoer, so BLP's liability had to be limited to its share. Buxton had recently gone into liquidation. BlueCross applied under r 23.02(a) to strike out the defence as futile, arguing that because it had pleaded only a contract claim against Buxton, and not a claim for failure to take reasonable care, Buxton could not be a concurrent wrongdoer at all.

What the court decided

Application dismissed. The strike out threshold is high, and on an interlocutory application the question is only whether the defence is arguable, not whether it will win. Her Honour found genuine doubt and debate in the authorities on two points: whether a person is a concurrent wrongdoer only where an apportionable claim is actually pleaded against them, and whether the court looks only at the pleaded claims or also at what might be found at trial about a failure to take reasonable care. Tanah Merah did not settle either question in the way BlueCross said. With that uncertainty, the defence was at least arguable and could not be called futile. Costs to be argued.

Why it matters

Strike out is for defences that cannot succeed, not defences that might not. Where the authorities on Part IVAA are genuinely unsettled, a proportionate liability defence stays in and the argument happens at trial.

What a junior would take from it

The test on a strike out is arguable, not persuasive. If you can find two lines of authority pointing different ways, you have already won the application.

Read the judgment (opens in a new tab)

Read next

The Kuala Lumpur internship: four weeks inside a civil litigation firm, Thomas Philip Advocates and Solicitors.